Graduate student or a candidate for the degree represents to the head of the department, laboratory the text of dissertations and theses, all scientific works, where the results of the research were published, primary documents that reflect the process of pilot or experimental work. So the dissertation discussion starts.
The head of the organization, where the research is performed, appoints 2 - 3 reviewers from the fields that can hold a qualified analysis of the thesis and major publications. The number of reviewers includes at least one Ph.D. - an expert on the topic of the dissertation. That is how a department prepares for the dissertation discussion.
Reviewers prepare written reviews of the thesis under consideration and submit it to the head unit.
Organization where you were working or to which you was attached, on the basis of submitted documents provides preliminary examination of the thesis and gives its opinion, where the main results of the study should be reflected.
The review must answer the following questions:
- Relevance of research topic and its connection with the plans of scientific research organizations, where the thesis was carried out;
- A specific author's personal involvement in obtaining new scientific results presented in the thesis;
- A degree of validity of scientific statements, conclusions and recommendations of the thesis;
- A conclusion on the completeness of published guidelines and the results of the research in scientific journals, scientific and practical significance of the findings and recommendations on their further use;
- Justification (if the thesis is made in the form of a scientific paper);
- Assessment of the structure of the thesis, the language and style of presentation of scientific material;
- Match of the theme of dissertation specialty, for which the dissertation council allowed to take the dissertation for defense. The review is the main key of the dissertation discussion.
The review should be submitted to the applicant within 10 days to discuss the thesis at a meeting of the department, laboratory.
Discussion of the thesis at its place of execution is valid if the meeting was attended by doctors of science, experts in the specialty profile of a dissertation or on scientific research.
Session Chair, Laboratory Division, registers in the minutes. The applicant is given an extract from the minutes of the meeting, signed by the head of department, laboratory and approved by the head of the organization is sealed.
The conclusion must be issued to the applicant within two months from the date of submission for the preliminary examination, dissertation.
That is how the dissertation discussion is done.
The head of the organization, where the research is performed, appoints 2 - 3 reviewers from the fields that can hold a qualified analysis of the thesis and major publications. The number of reviewers includes at least one Ph.D. - an expert on the topic of the dissertation. That is how a department prepares for the dissertation discussion.
Reviewers prepare written reviews of the thesis under consideration and submit it to the head unit.
Organization where you were working or to which you was attached, on the basis of submitted documents provides preliminary examination of the thesis and gives its opinion, where the main results of the study should be reflected.
The review must answer the following questions:
- Relevance of research topic and its connection with the plans of scientific research organizations, where the thesis was carried out;
- A specific author's personal involvement in obtaining new scientific results presented in the thesis;
- A degree of validity of scientific statements, conclusions and recommendations of the thesis;
- A conclusion on the completeness of published guidelines and the results of the research in scientific journals, scientific and practical significance of the findings and recommendations on their further use;
- Justification (if the thesis is made in the form of a scientific paper);
- Assessment of the structure of the thesis, the language and style of presentation of scientific material;
- Match of the theme of dissertation specialty, for which the dissertation council allowed to take the dissertation for defense. The review is the main key of the dissertation discussion.
The review should be submitted to the applicant within 10 days to discuss the thesis at a meeting of the department, laboratory.
Discussion of the thesis at its place of execution is valid if the meeting was attended by doctors of science, experts in the specialty profile of a dissertation or on scientific research.
Session Chair, Laboratory Division, registers in the minutes. The applicant is given an extract from the minutes of the meeting, signed by the head of department, laboratory and approved by the head of the organization is sealed.
The conclusion must be issued to the applicant within two months from the date of submission for the preliminary examination, dissertation.
That is how the dissertation discussion is done.